What Happened
In October 2026, the Delaware Court of Chancery reviewed a recapitalization transaction at Cloudflare, Inc. intended to preserve founder control. The court's preliminary findings revealed a special committee process compromised by autodeleting Signal chats, unauthorized side communications, and questionable use of AI tools. Directors initiated new Signal chats with autodeletion enabled during negotiations. A conflicted founder sent a committee member threatening messages with expletives, increasing the use of autodeleting chats. Despite anticipating litigation, no one disabled autodeletion until after the first litigation hold was issued. Some defendants delayed nearly two weeks before disabling Signal's autodeletion function. The court inferred negatively about the special committee's good faith, suggesting stockholder-plaintiffs might demonstrate at trial that the committee failed to act in good faith.
Timeline
During negotiations: Directors created new Signal chats with autodeletion enabled and shortened deletion periods in existing chats.
Late in negotiations: A conflicted founder sent threatening messages to a committee member, leading to increased use of autodeleting chats.
Same day as litigation warning: After being warned litigation was likely and evidence inconclusive, a committee member used an AI chatbot to identify an expert, with prompts deemed one-sided by the court.
After first litigation hold issued: Directors eventually disabled autodeletion. Some defendants took nearly two weeks to disable Signal's autodeletion function after receiving the hold.
October 16, 2026: The Delaware Court of Chancery issued its decision, drawing adverse inferences from the missing communications and credibility issues.
Which Controls Failed or Were Missing
Documentation protocols: The special committee lacked formal procedures for reporting material exchanges to the full committee and recording them in minutes. Unauthorized side communications with a conflicted founder were undocumented.
Communication governance: No initial rules governed appropriate channels for committee business or message retention duration. The rise in autodeleting chats after threatening messages indicates a lack of oversight.
Preservation procedures: Despite anticipating litigation, participants delayed disabling autodeletion features. The nearly two-week delay by some defendants after receiving a litigation hold highlights inadequate preservation protocols.
Technology use guidelines: The committee lacked standards for AI tool use in governance processes. The court found AI prompts focused on the proposal's "benefits" without considering "downsides," suggesting the chatbot was used for confirmatory evidence rather than objective analysis.
Board independence safeguards: A non-committee director's attempt to intervene in special committee deliberations at a conflicted founder's request indicated insufficient boundaries protecting the committee's independence.
What Section 144 Requires
Section 144 of the Delaware General Corporation Law provides protections for conflicted transactions when properly implemented. The statute requires fidelity in execution. While it doesn't prescribe specific documentation methods, Delaware case law requires a credible contemporaneous record to demonstrate good faith and independent judgment.
The court emphasized that the special committee's ability to say "no" is crucial. This independence must be genuine. When conflicted parties make threats or seek private assurances outside formal channels, the committee must document those interactions and its response. The court noted that Section 144's protections, referred to as the "General Controller Safe Harbor," were likely to apply if not for the defendants' credibility problems.
Delaware courts can draw adverse inferences from missing evidence without a formal spoliation motion. As the court stated, it "can review the record to assess what inferences the Signal use, together with the associated gaps in the record, supports." A party's failure to produce strong evidence that should have been available can support an inference that the missing evidence would have been adverse.
Lessons and Action Items for Your Team
Establish communication protocols before negotiations begin. Before your next conflicted transaction, document which channels are appropriate for committee business, how long messages must be retained, and which communications require reporting to the full committee. Don't wait until after threatening messages or litigation holds to consider preservation.
Meet as a committee with advisors present. Conduct substantive deliberations with your legal and financial advisors present, whether in person or virtually. This practice creates a complete record and discourages conflicted parties from making threats or seeking private assurances. Report material exchanges outside formal meetings to the full committee and include them in minutes.
Structure advisor compensation to support independence. Ensure your financial advisor receives meaningful compensation even if the transaction doesn't close. Consider a fairness opinion fee payable regardless of the conclusion reached. While contingent fees are customary, compensation structures that reward the work even when the answer is "no" reinforce your committee's credibility.
Treat AI prompts as discoverable evidence. If committee members use AI tools for research or analysis, assume those prompts will become part of the evidentiary record. Frame prompts to seek balanced analysis, not confirmatory evidence. Ask about both benefits and downsides. Establish guidelines for AI use in governance processes before someone opens a chatbot during sensitive negotiations.
Implement immediate preservation when litigation is anticipated. The moment you anticipate litigation, identify relevant participants, devices, and channels. Confirm that relevant communications can be preserved and are being preserved. Disable autodeletion features immediately. Don't wait for a formal litigation hold. The court rejected the argument that it couldn't draw inferences from missing messages absent a spoliation motion.
Protect special committee independence from the full board. When non-committee directors attempt to intervene in special committee deliberations at the request of conflicted parties, document those attempts and the committee's consideration of them. Make clear that the special committee operates independently.
The Cloudflare decision confirms that structured communication and documentation practices are essential in corporate governance to safeguard against legal vulnerabilities in conflicted transactions. A contemporaneous record that faithfully captures independent deliberation protects the legal safe harbors Delaware law provides. Missing communications and unexplained deletion settings invite judicial second-guessing. In the informal world of short-form messaging, where cryptic exchanges are susceptible to misinterpretation, disciplined documentation practices become your strongest defense.





