Skip to main content
Promotional banner for the pentest readiness checklist
SEC Exam Priorities Test Whether Controls Actually Workgeneral
4 min readFor Compliance Officers

SEC Exam Priorities Test Whether Controls Actually Work

By Governance AuthorityPublished

The SEC's Division of Examinations has published its fiscal year 2027 examination priorities. This document, while not legally binding, serves as a crucial guide to examination risk. The central focus is clear: examiners want to know if your controls are operational and if you can prove their effectiveness.

Examination Focus Areas

The priorities highlight conflicts of interest, supervision, AI oversight, cybersecurity, and vendor risk. Although not exhaustive, this list may evolve with emerging risks or market changes. Across these areas, a consistent requirement emerges: policies must be well-designed, implemented, and demonstrably effective.

For compliance officers, this shifts the focus from drafting policies to proving their functionality. Examiners will request evidence of control effectiveness, such as records of reviews, escalations, and resolutions.

Key Findings

1. Conflict-of-Interest Policies: Examiners will assess the implementation of conflict-of-interest policies, not just their drafting. For investment advisers, this includes evaluating whether policies address fee-related conflicts tied to compensation. Broker-dealers must demonstrate how conflicts are identified and mitigated under Regulation Best Interest. Dual registrants are a priority, especially regarding compensation incentives and account-selection decisions. The Division's June 2026 risk alert on economic conflicts of interest provides examples of staff observations.

2. AI Oversight: The Division will scrutinize policies and procedures for AI monitoring, including its use in fraud prevention, back-office operations, AML, and trading. Examiners will verify that representations about automated tools are accurate. The AI tools you use for risk management are under examination.

3. Employee-Adopted AI Tools: Tools like ChatGPT and Claude, adopted without vetting, pose risks. You must address what data enters these tools, ensure outputs align with disclosures, and determine which interactions require retention or supervision.

4. Cybersecurity and Vendor Oversight: Examiners will evaluate incident response programs for unauthorized access to customer information, including customer notification and service provider oversight. Regulation S-ID red flags, such as account takeovers and fraudulent transfers, and preparation for AI-generated phishing and deepfake threats, are also highlighted. Vendor due diligence under Regulation S-P will receive increased scrutiny.

5. Marketing and Disclosure Accuracy: The accuracy of marketing and disclosures hinges on retrievable evidence. For broker-dealers, the Division will review Regulation Best Interest disclosure obligations and Form CRS content. The key question is whether you can demonstrate what investors were told and how concerns were resolved.

Implications for Your Organization

Consider the priorities as an evidence standard. Under frameworks like the COSO ERM Framework, control activities are credible only if monitoring confirms their function. Examiners apply the same logic: a control without a reviewable record is effectively non-existent.

Two practical implications arise:

First, retrieval speed is critical. If supervisory reviews are documented in ways that delay retrieval, this is a readiness gap, even if the review occurred. Completeness and accessibility of records are integral to control effectiveness.

Second, structural conflict controls need reassessment. For firms with multiple business lines, test whether access controls and information barriers rely solely on ethical walls. While the SEC doesn't use this term, it's a reasonable check on conflict control effectiveness.

Several indicators suggest reassessment is necessary:

  • Conflict-of-interest policies haven't been updated since growth, service additions, or acquisitions.
  • Controls between advisory and brokerage activities primarily depend on ethical walls.
  • There's no current inventory of AI tools used in compliance, trading, AML, or client-facing work.
  • The incident response plan lacks clarity on customer notification and service-provider responsibilities.

These indicators don't necessarily signal gaps but highlight areas for initial review.

Action Items by Priority

Priority 1: Inventory and Govern AI Tools. Identify where AI supports compliance, trading, AML, and client communications. Document validation, monitoring, ownership, and escalation for each tool. Establish an approved-tools list, usage policies, AI-assisted work reviews, and a decision on record retention.

Priority 2: Test Conflict-of-Interest Controls. Ensure conflict policies are implemented as designed, including compensation incentives and account-selection practices. Confirm controls extend beyond information barriers. Retain testing results as evidence.

Priority 3: Pressure-Test Incident Response and Vendor Oversight. Verify response procedures cover unauthorized access, customer notification, and service-provider responsibilities. Refresh due diligence files for critical vendors and document evaluation and monitoring processes.

Priority 4: Align Marketing and Disclosure Review. Ensure marketing, recommendations, and disclosures are documented, consistent with investor communications, and retrievable upon request.

Priority 5: Prepare for the Examination Process. The Division has published the SEC Exam Handbook, detailing the examination stages. Use it to ensure your team is prepared and can efficiently produce records. Maintain complete and easily retrievable supervisory reviews, escalations, and resolutions.

Begin with the area most relevant to your firm's business. Monitor upcoming risk alerts and examination observations to identify common shortcomings.

Topics:general
Promotional banner for the CUI buildout guide

You Might Also Like