Compliance teams have been grappling with questions since the recent changes in UK employment law and the proposed amendments to Germany's Administrative Offences Act (OWiG). Below are the most frequently asked questions, with answers grounded in the legal provisions.
Q1: We already have a harassment policy and annual training. Doesn't that satisfy "all reasonable steps"?
No, it doesn't. From October 30, 2026, section 20 of the Employment Rights Act 2025 updates the Worker Protection Act standard from "reasonable steps" to "all reasonable steps." Previously, having a policy or training program might have sufficed. Now, the question is whether there was any reasonable step you could have taken but didn't.
Reasonable steps vary with your organization's size and resources, but generally include training with completion records, a defined policy with tracked acknowledgements, clear reporting instructions, and an anonymous whistleblowing channel. Without these, it's difficult to argue that all reasonable steps were taken. Each element requires evidence. A policy without proof of receipt is a weak defense.
Q2: How do we prove we took "all reasonable steps" if a claim lands two years from now?
Establish an evidence trail as a continuous control, not just a litigation response. Treat it like any control in your COSO ERM Framework: document the risk, assign a control owner, test it, and retain evidence.
This involves maintaining completion logs linked to individuals and dates, version-controlled policies with acknowledgements, documented reporting routes, and records of how the whistleblowing channel is promoted and monitored. Conduct periodic reviews to determine if further reasonable steps are necessary, adopting them or recording why they aren't reasonable. This step is crucial under the new wording, as the test is exhaustive.
Note that tribunal time limits for claims like harassment and discrimination extend from three to six months starting October 1, 2026, in England, Wales, and Scotland. Your evidence must endure a longer period before a claim is filed.
Q3: Does the new duty really cover customers and contractors? We can't discipline them.
Yes, it does. From October 30, employers must take all reasonable steps to prevent harassment of employees by third parties, including contractors, customers, clients, employees of a parent company, and the public. It covers all Equality Act protected characteristics, not just sex, so race, disability, religion, and age are included.
While you can't fire a customer, you can refuse their business. You need a policy defining when you'll do this, and your staff must be aware of it. Pair this with training, a reporting mechanism, and a system that proves completion and acknowledgement. Tribunals can award uncapped compensation for injury to feelings and financial loss, and the Equality and Human Rights Commission can impose compliance measures.
Q4: Our right-to-work process only covers employees. What changed on October 1?
Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 expands right-to-work verification. It now includes:
- Individuals under a "worker's contract," covering casual, zero-hours, bank, seasonal, and temporary staff.
- Individual subcontractors, meaning self-employed individuals doing subcontracted work. Sole traders with their own clients are excluded.
- People matched to work by online platforms, such as delivery and ride-hailing services. Platforms must verify at least once in any 24 hours of activity that the worker is the person checked.
These duties apply to engagements starting on or after October 1, 2026, with no retrospective checks required. Checks must be completed before the first shift. Civil penalties can reach £45,000 for a first breach and £60,000 for a repeat within three years. Criminal liability includes up to five years' imprisonment and an unlimited fine if the business knew or should have known the person had no right to work.
Q5: We subcontract a lot. Are we really liable for people we never engaged?
Yes, you are. If Firm A takes a delivery job and passes it to Firm B, and Firm B's driver lacks the right to work, Firm A can be held liable. The subcontractor is responsible for the check, but you share the risk. This also applies when a contract allows an individual to send a substitute, and to platforms whose service providers are companies.
The statutory excuse requires three elements, which your third-party risk process should ensure before work begins:
- A signed agreement committing the subcontractor or labor supplier to conduct right-to-work checks.
- Evidence of their substitution process, showing checks on substitutes.
- Evidence of their identity verification process, confirming the identity of workers.
These should be onboarding requirements, not post-audit findings. A contract clause without evidence of the processes doesn't suffice.
Q6: Germany is only a draft. Why would we act on it now?
Because building the necessary evidence takes time. A May 2026 draft bill implementing the EU Environmental Crime Directive proposes changes to Section 30 of the OWiG. If adopted, it would extend beyond environmental offenses to fraud, bribery, sanctions breaches, and money laundering. The proposed maximum fine for intentional violations would rise from €10 million to €40 million, and for negligent violations from €5 million to €20 million. Profit forfeiture is uncapped, so total exposure is unlimited.
The draft introduces a potential fine reduction for companies with an effective compliance program, a serious internal investigation, and remediation. "Serious" isn't defined, leaving it to prosecutors. The investigation must be independent; if investigators were involved in the misconduct, no reduction applies (explanatory memorandum to § 30(2a) s. 3 no. 5, BT-Drs. 21/6133). The program must prevent misconduct, be operational, and address real risks. A system used to conceal misconduct can increase the fine.
Test your readiness with a mock investigation over 48 hours and identify gaps. Keep reports, investigations, training records, and risk assessments accessible for authorities.
Where to go for more
Review section 20 of the Employment Rights Act 2025 and section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, along with Home Office and Equality and Human Rights Commission guidance. For Germany, monitor the draft Section 30 OWiG amendment and the explanatory memorandum (BT-Drs. 21/6133) through the legislative process. Your board's Audit and Risk Committee should receive a gap assessment on all three areas, with named owners and evidence standards, before the October deadlines.





