Introduction
COSO has issued guiding principles for board oversight, developed with PwC. There are 12 principles, designed to be principles-based rather than prescriptive. This approach was chosen after a more prescriptive attempt in 2025 was poorly received and subsequently withdrawn. The current version is streamlined and widely accepted.
While the guidance is aimed at boards, its value for internal auditors lies in the shared vocabulary it creates. Jim DeLoach of Protiviti views the principles as a common language for audit, risk, and compliance professionals who support the governance process. This checklist treats the principles as an audit and assurance reference, not a mandate. COSO states the guidance is directional and illustrative, complementing, not replacing, applicable law, regulation, and other recognized governance guidance. Nothing here should be presented to your audit committee as a compliance obligation.
Each item includes a done/not-done test and a description of what good looks like.
Prerequisites
Before you start, confirm these four points:
- Access. Ensure you have the current COSO publication, your board charter, committee charters, and delegation-of-authority documents.
- Scope decision. Agree with your chief audit executive whether this is an assurance engagement, an advisory review, or an input to the board's own self-assessment.
- Regulatory map. Maintain a current list of the laws, listing standards, and codes that bind your organization. If operating in the UK, include the UK Corporate Governance Code, which applies on an Apply and Explain basis. The COSO principles complement these; they don't displace them.
- Mapping to COSO ERM Framework. If your organization uses the COSO ERM Framework, identify where it already addresses Principle 12 (risk management and internal control).
The Checklist
1. Map the 12 principles to your existing governance documents.
Build a crosswalk from each principle to the charter, policy, or committee terms of reference that already addresses it. Done when every principle has a documented owner and source document, or a recorded gap.
What good looks like: A single crosswalk the audit committee has seen, with gaps stated plainly rather than papered over.
2. Test governance structure and role clarity (Principle 1).
Confirm that roles, delegated authorities, and committee functions are defined and aligned with mission, strategy, risk appetite, and legal requirements. Done when you've compared committee mandates for overlap and omission.
What good looks like: No oversight topic lacks a committee home, and no topic has two committees each assuming the other covers it.
3. Assess accountability and Governance Disclosure (Principle 2).
Review whether disclosures to shareholders or other beneficiaries are complete, accurate, and timely, and whether legal and governance-standard compliance is monitored. Done when you've traced at least one disclosure from source data to publication.
What good looks like: A documented review chain with named sign-offs and a record of how errors are escalated.
4. Evaluate board composition, independence, and succession (Principle 3).
Check that skills coverage, independence from management, and leadership succession are reviewed on a regular cycle. Done when the review exists, has a date, and has been acted on.
What good looks like: A skills matrix tied to strategy and emerging risks, refreshed on a defined cycle, with succession plans for chair and committee chairs.
5. Confirm board effectiveness is self-assessed (Principle 4).
Verify that the board assesses its own performance and refines its practices. Done when you've seen the most recent assessment output and the resulting action list.
What good looks like: Actions from the last assessment are tracked to closure, not filed.
6. Review alignment of purpose, mission, and values (Principle 5).
Test whether values are reflected in strategy, culture, incentive compensation structures, and workforce practices. Done when you've sampled at least one decision or incentive plan against stated values.
What good looks like: Observable links between stated values and how people are rewarded and promoted.
7. Assess culture, conduct, and tone at the top (Principle 6).
Examine how the board sets and models expectations for integrity, and how it learns of conduct issues. Done when you've reviewed speak-up reporting routes to the board and the board's response to the last significant conduct matter.
What good looks like: The board receives conduct information unfiltered by the executives it concerns.
8. Test strategy and performance monitoring (Principle 7).
Confirm the board receives performance information measured against agreed objectives, and that incentives align with purpose, risk appetite, and long-term value. Done when you've compared board reporting to approved strategic objectives. Where non-financial performance metrics feed incentives, confirm they're defined and verifiable.
What good looks like: Board packs trace directly to objectives, and metrics have owners and evidence.
9. Review oversight of technology and data (Principle 8).
Verify that technology and data practices are overseen against strategy and risk appetite. Done when you've identified who reports on this to the board and how often.
What good looks like: Technology and data risk appear in board discussion as a strategic and resilience matter, not only as an incident report.
10. Assess stakeholder engagement oversight (Principle 9).
Check how management identifies stakeholders, how the board receives their feedback, and when directors engage directly. Done when you can show a feedback item that reached the board and influenced a strategic discussion.
What good looks like: Communication is balanced and credible, with a clear route from stakeholder input to board agenda.
11. Test executive succession and performance oversight (Principles 10 and 11).
Review CEO and key executive succession plans, talent pipeline reviews, and the process for approving compensation plans. Done when you've confirmed the Remuneration Committee, or equivalent, reviews performance before approving awards. Where malus and clawback or recovery of erroneously awarded compensation policies apply, confirm they're documented and tested.
What good looks like: Pay outcomes reconcile to documented performance assessments, and recovery provisions are operable, not theoretical.
12. Validate risk management and internal control oversight (Principle 12).
Confirm the board oversees management's risk approach, monitoring, and assurance activities. Done when you've verified the board sees assurance reporting from all lines, including internal audit, and challenges it.
What good looks like: Assurance coverage is mapped to principal risks, and the board can show it asked difficult questions.
Common Mistakes
- Treating the principles as a compliance standard. They're illustrative. Reporting "non-compliance with COSO" misstates their status.
- Scoring all 12 equally. Weight your review by risk and by where the organization is in transition, such as a leadership change or a material transaction.
- Ignoring existing requirements. The principles complement listing standards, regulation, and case-law-based expectations. They never override them.
- Producing a checklist the board never sees. A crosswalk held only inside internal audit won't change board behavior.
- Over-engineering. The earlier prescriptive version failed for this reason. Keep your use of the principles proportionate.
Next Steps
Start with a limited scope. Use the principles on governance structure, accountability, composition, culture, and stakeholder engagement as opening questions for a conversation with your chair or corporate secretary. Then use the crosswalk to propose the principles as a shared reference for board self-assessments, committee agendas, and director onboarding.
Finally, record where information flows or accountability are unclear. That's where a common language pays off, and where your function can show its value beyond the audit plan.




