Budget pressure on compliance functions often comes with a familiar argument: compliance generates no revenue, enforcement has eased, and better tools mean a leaner team can do the same work. While technology does improve efficiency, the idea that compliance is merely overhead to be minimized is flawed. Recent enforcement history underscores the importance of maintaining robust compliance programs.
This checklist helps you determine whether your compliance program is a strategic asset or merely a cost line. Each item has a clear done/not-done state and a description of what effective compliance looks like. It is designed for compliance officers who need to resist budget cuts or reshape them into risk-based modernization.
Prerequisites
Before you begin, gather the following:
- Your current compliance budget and headcount, with a two-to-three-year trend
- Your enterprise risk register, ideally mapped to the COSO ERM Framework components
- Your organization chart showing the Chief Compliance Officer's reporting line
- A log of compliance recommendations and the business response to each
- Results of recent monitoring, screening, and control testing
Checklist
1. Map your exposure to current enforcement priorities.
Do not assume that the pause and narrowing of FCPA enforcement indicate a general decline in risk. The Justice Department's National Fraud Enforcement Division issued a directive on Oct. 1 naming four priority categories: healthcare fraud, government procurement and contracts fraud, tax and revenue evasion, and trade fraud, including tariff evasion and forced labor. Done means your risk assessment is updated against all four categories, with each applicable one having an owner.
Good looks like: a dated risk assessment showing which priority categories affect your operations, with controls mapped to each.
2. Quantify exposure in financial terms.
Training completion rates describe activity, not risk. Estimate what a sanctions miss, a customs misclassification, or a monitoring gap would cost at your scale, including investigation, remediation, and monitorship costs. Done means leadership has seen a financial exposure range, not an activity report.
Good looks like: a one-page exposure summary that a CFO can read without translation.
3. Test whether compliance can stop a transaction or relationship.
Visibility without authority is a core failure in the Bank of America matter. Compliance personnel identified in July 2022 that a customer relationship carried too much risk and recommended closing the accounts. The relationship team cited about $6 million in annual revenue, a mitigation plan replaced closure, and the customer kept processing payments until June 2025. Done means your policies state who may hold or stop a relationship, and who may overrule that decision.
Good looks like: a documented escalation path where any override of a compliance recommendation requires senior sign-off and is recorded.
4. Review the override log.
Pull every instance in the past two years where compliance recommended against a transaction, customer, or initiative, and record the outcome. Zero recommendations is not reassurance; it suggests compliance is not being consulted or heard. Frequent overrides require board visibility. Done means the log exists and has been reviewed.
Good looks like: a log that the board or audit committee examines at least annually.
5. Confirm the CCO's stature and reporting line.
A CCO buried several layers down reduces who hears the warning. Done means the CCO has direct access to the board or a designated committee and a seat in senior decision forums.
Good looks like: private sessions between the CCO and the board, held on a fixed schedule and minuted.
6. Protect the independence of testing.
FinCEN's order described a test of the bank's monitoring system whose result senior leadership disliked; the head of financial crimes had the test repeated, and the second test declared the system "working as intended." Done means your policy prohibits re-running a test to obtain a preferred result without documented methodological justification.
Good looks like: testing protocols that fix methodology in advance and route unfavorable results to the audit committee.
7. Validate monitoring and screening logic, not just coverage.
A 12-person freight forwarder, Pegasus Worldwide Logistics, paid $175,015 to OFAC over a $5,950 machine because its screening was late and looked only at a name. Done means screening timing and matching logic have been independently validated.
Good looks like: documented validation showing screening occurs before the transaction and covers more than name matching.
8. Build the technology case on risk, not headcount.
Automation and analytics are legitimate efficiency tools, and the government is using data analytics to detect problems. Done means any proposed technology investment is tied to a defined risk outcome and validated before headcount is reduced.
Good looks like: a business case showing detection capability before and after, with a validation step preceding any staffing change.
9. Define red lines in writing.
Identify the functions that cannot be cut without raising risk beyond tolerance. Done means leadership has either accepted those red lines or formally accepted the residual risk in writing.
Good looks like: a signed risk acceptance, referenced in board minutes.
10. Verify speak-up channels and whistleblower readiness.
The NFED directive points to whistleblower incentives that reach even insiders who took part in the conduct. Done means your hotline is tested, retaliation protections are documented, and case handling is timely.
Good looks like: a reporting channel that surfaces issues while they are still inexpensive to fix.
Common Mistakes
- Reading one statute as the whole landscape. Narrower FCPA enforcement reflects reallocation, not retreat.
- Counting cost avoided as savings. FinCEN concluded the bank had likely saved hundreds of millions of dollars in compliance spending while problems persisted. Remediation is expected to require roughly 750 additional staff and 800 consultants, and the bank announced a $1.2 billion charge for penalties alone.
- Presenting activity metrics to a financial audience.
- Assuming a function that exists is a function that works. Bank of America had a compliance function that saw the problem. It lacked the authority to act on it.
- Ignoring indirect costs. Monitorships, debarment risk, higher cost of capital, executive turnover, and lost trust often exceed the penalty.
Next Steps
Score each item as done or not done. Any "not done" in items 3, 4, 5, or 6 should go to your audit committee promptly, since those items address authority and independence rather than resources. Then take items 2, 8, and 9 into your next budget discussion: show the exposure, offer risk-based modernization as the alternative to across-the-board cuts, and put the residual risk decision in writing where leadership must own it.
Rebuilding a program after a failure costs more than maintaining one. Your task is to make that arithmetic visible before the invoice arrives.





